Her own story with antidepressants began
after a breakup during her first year at col-lege. A 20-minute consultation with a coun-
oundup selor at the campus health center resulted
in a prescription for Zoloft. While the pills brought strength and calm (her words), they
versity of New York and an award-winning
cognitive scientist, Jesse Prinz’s Beyond
Since it is highly influenced by both biology
and culture, Prinz wraps up with the topic of
see antidepressants as bringing them back
sex: “No aspect of human life better illustrates
to their “old self,” whereas adolescents who
the way in which something natural can be
are searching for their identity don’t have an
at the same time thoroughly cultural.” From
“old self” to return to. She writes, “Lacking
beauty standards and gender stereotypes to
a reliable conception of what it is to feel ‘like
sexual preferences and taboos, Prinz demon-
themselves,’ young people have no way to
From a nurture perspective, we gain a better
strates how difficult it becomes to define the
gauge the effects of the drugs on their devel-
understanding of the inner workings of human
line between culture and biology. “The story
of sex is the story of our species. Here as
Prinz offers up a slew of reasons to defend
elsewhere, we are always moving beyond hu-
way or the other for the use or disuse of
his stance that “our capacity to change with
man nature.” Exploring the horizon of our bio-
antidepressants. Rather, she offers a prism
circumstances demonstrates that biology is
cultural reality will serve to give us a deeper
not the complete story.” Prinz critiques the
understanding of the interaction between us
others’, giving the reader an honest, multi-
approaches that so heavily rely on biology as
and our environment. —Britt Keller
layered picture inside the mind and heart
he explores the frontier of cultural psychol-
of the drug user. She ends the book with an
ogy. Intriguingly, he began mapping out the
earnest focus on the current generation,
whose overly pressured drive for accomplish-
sociologists, criminologists, linguists, geog-
ment is responsible for the prevalence of
raphers, economists, psychologists and neu-
pharmaceuticals in everyday life. To describe
roscientists, benefitting from being front and
the unrealistic expectations of this driven
center of the nature-nurture debate.
generation, Sharpe quotes a psychiatrist who
treats many Manhattan college students and
Prinz directs our attention to the fact that
recent grads: “[Being] able to work fourteen
vast differences in perception, intelligence
hours a day, and then go out and have a social
The World Health Organization identifies
life, and maintain a certain weight, and not
cultural (rather than biological) causes. While
depression as the leading cause of disability
be exhausted…There’s a sense that they’re
naturists focus on fixity, nurturists are more
worldwide. In 2012, Prozac turns 25 years
concerned with flexibility—human potential.
old, and SSRI antidepressants have become
thing possible that’s not healthy or normal.”
While most of both fronts agree that both
the most-used class of drugs in America.
Disconnect, culture of silence, the high rate
nature and nurture hold importance, there
With the advent of neuroscientific research
of depression in young women—these are but
are many positions to be held in the spectrum
providing the biomedical model of mental
a few of the issues affecting this generation
between the two. Prinz tells the story from
illness as a chemical imbalance, drug use in
which Sharpe explores with a deep empathy.
where biology leaves off. Through exploring
general is supplanting traditional methods of
That Dr. David Healy, author of the ground-
the sources of knowledge and language, think-
talk therapy. In 2008, 5 percent of US teenag-
breaking Let Them Eat Prozac and The Anti-
ing, feeling and values, Prinz shows us ways in
ers took an antidepressant, and the number
depressant Era, gives a nod to Sharpe’s book
which we transcend nature. Since all of these
increases each year, as doctors have begun
is impressive and noteworthy. He writes,
traits involve an interaction between biology
prescribing these medications to younger and
“This is a book for anyone taking or think-
and the environment, they can be referred to
ing about taking antidepressants, anyone
In this probing and beautifully written book,
author Katherine Sharpe explores how this
about their suitability—or anyone who wants
class of drugs has affected young people,
a mirror held up to our time.” And we agree.
their parents, doctors and society in general.
—Margaret Emory
Through the sharing of her personal story as a user, compelling interviews with her peers and their relationships to SSRIs plus scientific and sociological research, Sharpe describes how the generation of the mid-’70s to 80s—the first to have been raised on psychiatric drugs—altered the definition of mentally ill, anxiety disorders, wellness and self-identity.
COENZYME Q10 (COQ10) DEFICIENCY & RISK FACTORS “Treatment of periodontitis with CoEnyme Q10 [was so ‘extraordinarily effective’ that it] should be considered as adjunctive treatment with current dental practice.”35 “…topical application of CoQ10 improves adult periodontitis not only as a sole treatment but also in combination with traditional nonsurgical periodontal