Dear Colleague, Thank you for requesting information on the GreenLight laser prostatectomy technique. I have been performing The GreenLight PVP (Photoselective Vaporisation of the Prostate) since
September 2002 and, as of February have treated over 900 patients (our data has been presented at the European, American and British Annual Urological Meetings, and published in a number of international journals). The short term results compare very favourably with conventional surgery with dramatically reduced bleeding, hospital stay and recovery time. In the medium to long term the
results appear to be as good as we would expect with TURP, with durable flow and symptoms improvements to 3 years.
I was recently privileged to use as the first surgeon in Europe the latest model of the GreenLight, TheHPS (High Performance System) with results that seem even better than with the currently available version of the GreenLight PVP.
In patients with very large prostates who are normally treated by open surgery we have shown that the procedure can be carried out safely (even in high risk patients) with good results. For patients in retention of urine, more than 95% can expect to be catheter free after GreenLight surgery. Even patients with concurrent bladder stones or hernias can often leave hospital the same day without a
catheter. Should you wish any abstracts or journal articles on these results we will be happy to forward them.
It is necessary to consult with patients prior to surgery, but to reduce inconvenience to patients, I try to make my clinic visits “one stop.” To assist in this, we like to have as much information on patients as possible prior to seeing them. The following pages should help with this.
I hope you will find this information pack of help, as there are a number of areas which are common to all patients having the procedure. I hope you will find this timesaving, helpful and straightforward. We appreciate any comments with regard to this.
GREENLI GHT PVP INFORMATION PACK FROM MR G. MUIR
This describes the procedure involved in having a
After passing water you can usually leave
prostate operation. This procedure has in my
hospital; if a catheter is left in place this is
practice replaced the previous “gold standard” of
removed the following morning unless there has
TURP and is usually carried out as a day-case
been a previous problem with retention of urine
procedure.
in which case I may recommend leaving it for a
You will have discussed the reasons behind having
the surgery, which are to relieve the obstruction
Following the Operation
to the flow of urine through the prostate by
removing the central part of the prostate.
This operation is done usually for benign (non-
Some men may fail to pass water after the
cancerous) swelling of the prostate although it
operation: this is much more common if the
may be used to relieve the obstruction of a
surgery is being done where the bladder has been
prostate cancer. However it does not remove the
stretched or is emptying poorly and this would be
whole prostate and is not a “cancer curing”
In men with good bladder emptying there is still a
possibility of around 5% of some difficulty passing
HOW IS THE OPERATION CARRIED OUT?
urine after the catheter is removed: this may
require a short period with a small soft catheter
Day-Case Procedure
to rest the bladder but has no long term ill
No special preparation for the surgery (i.e.
shaving or diet) is required. You will usually come
in on the day of the operation and should starve
for at least six hours prior to the scheduled
Following the operation it is usual to have mild
discomfort only. The majority of men will need
Medication
only simple painkillers, although some may need
tablets to calm bladder spasm. You will be given
You need not stop aspirin or other anti-platelet
regular Voltarol painkillers and also a few days of
drugs prior to the operation but if you are taking
an antibiotic. About one man in ten will have
warfarin or heparin then it is imperative that
bothersome discomfort needing a longer course
the dosage of this is monitored or modified. In this case please make sure you have a copy of our protocol for managing anticoagulation. Light Anaesthetic
Despite the absence of a cut in the skin, this is
still classified as a major operation. There may
The operation is carried out under light general
be bleeding at the time of surgery or later: so far
(asleep) anaesthetic, with local anaesthetic being
no patients have had life threatening bleeding.
given around the prostate. Spinal anaesthesia can
be used but if it is then a catheter must be left in
medication) has required blood transfusion at the
the bladder after the operation. We prefer not to
time of surgery. Advances in anaesthetic
use sedation and local anaesthetic unless
techniques reduce the risk of serious chest
absolutely necessary, since most men will have
Small Catheter
A telescope (cystoscope) is passed into the
bladder, which is examined. The obstructing prostate tissue is then vaporised using the high
powered laser. A small catheter (soft plastic drainage tube) may be placed in the bladder to
drain the urine if there is any concern about bladder contractility, but it is not usually
required for bleeding even in the largest prostates.
WHAT ARE THE SIDE EFFECTS?
confirm that obstruction is present. Despite this
about one man in six with these symptoms may
Retrograde Ejaculation
find they persist post operatively, due we
presume to a primary overactivity of the bladder.
If this does happen there are medical treatments
ejaculation, which is when the semen falls back
into the bladder instead of coming out through
the penis. This seems to affect about 30-60% of
Bleeding
men after PVP, depending on the prostate size
(with TURP the figure was 80%) Some men may
Severe bleeding is uncommon after PVP, but you
feel the orgasm to be somewhat less intense if
will probably pass a little blood in the first few
this happens, but usually learn to appreciate the
weeks, particularly at the start of the urine
sensations again. Our impression is that this side
stream. If bleeding is a major problem then it is
effect is commoner with larger prostates.
important to drink well and to have a urine
Retrograde ejaculation may cause sterility but
sample checked to rule out urinary infection.
cannot be relied upon as a form of contraception
since some sperms may still be expelled.
It is sensible to avoid very heavy lifting for three
weeks after the operation since any sudden
Low Risk of Impotence
increase in abdominal pressure can cause
So far there are no reports of significant
impotence after the operation, but there remains
Returning to Normal Activities
a theoretical risk that this could occur if the laser
were to be used too close to the penile nerves.
Driving presents no problem. You can return to
work when you feel fit and depending on your
Prostate Regrowth
job: usually no more than a week off is needed
but some men have gone back to work within 48
Since not the entire prostate is removed,
regrowth can occur. The figures from TURP
suggest that one man in seven will need revision
Exercise and Intercourse
surgery over a ten-year period due to prostate
regrowth. It is likely that this will be similar with
Sport or sexual activity can be resumed as soon
PVP. As with TURP, there may be formation of
as you feel fit. On resumption of intercourse, if
scar tissue (a stricture) following the operation
you do ejaculate normally, it is likely there will
which can require a minor operation to put it
be blood or discolouration of the semen. This is
right. The risk of this with TURP is around 5% and
nothing to worry about and will not harm your
Low Risk of Incontinence Mental Effects
Lastly, as with TURP, incontinence may very
After any surgery you may feel tired and a bit
rarely occur. The risk of incontinence due to
emotional for a number of weeks. This is quite
damage to the sphincter muscle, in my hands, is
normal, but if you feel depressed it is important
around one in 300. This is a treatable problem.
HOW LONG DOES RECOVERY TAKE? WHAT FOLLOW-UP IS REQUIRED? Symptoms
If all goes smoothly a telephone check within the
first ten days will make sure there are no major
We have observed most patients to have a halving
problems. I like to have a check after three to
or more of their symptoms within six weeks of
four months to make sure the symptoms and
surgery. However, the bladder may be overactive
urine flow have improved as expected, and if
for a few weeks after the operation, giving a
sense of things getting worse before getting
better. It is thus sensible to avoid any long journeys after the procedure for a few weeks.
Bladder function can keep improving for up to four months after the procedure.
If urgency and getting up at night are major problems prior to the operation, or if there is any
history of incontinence, I will usually have
PRE -OP TEST RESULTS AND INFORMATION REQUIRED
TESTS
A number of tests are needed to assess a man’s suitability for this operation. If you have previously seen another specialist and a letter has been sent to me then I will usually have these results.
Otherwise it is a good idea to try to get the tests organised at the time of the first appointment. My PA will
help you with this if need be. You may find the check box below helpful.
Result Available? Serum PSA Blood test: needs to be done prior to outpatient visit Serum Creatinine Blood test: needs to be done prior to outpatient visit Full Blood Count Blood test: needs to be done prior to outpatient visit Urine Flow rate Urine test: can be done at time of assessment Urine residual volume Ultrasound: can be done at time of assessment Urine culture or urinalysis Urine test: can be done at time of assessment
If your PSA is raised you may have had a TRUS and Biopsy test: if so I will also need to see the results of these.
In addition, for some men it may be necessary to carry out a flexible cystoscopy if there is any doubt as to whether a blockage is due to the prostate gland or possibly a stricture (scarring in the pipe between the
prostate and the penis) If the prostate is very large I may recommend a special ultrasound assessment (TRUS) to determine whether pre-treatment for a couple of weeks with a drug to reduce prostate blood flow is advisable, and to accurately
estimate the correct amount of laser energy to use. Both the cystoscopy and the TRUS test can be carried out in the clinic without affecting your activity thereafter. Lastly, as part of my commitment to evaluating and improving my technique, I collect information on prostate and erectile symptoms in all my patients. It would be helpful from this point of view if you would be kind
enough to fill in the last pages of this pack
• INTERNATIONAL PROSTATE SYMPTOM SCORE (IPSS) on Page 6
• MODIFIED INTERNATIONAL INDEX OF ERECTILE FUNCTION (IIEF-5) on Page 7
These details will be kept absolutely confidential but will allow an assessment of the benefits of the procedure
both for you, and hopefully for others in future.
INTERNATIONAL PROSTATE SYMPTO M SCORE (IPSS)
This score gives an idea of the symptoms and bother you are suffering. Use the following point scale to answer
each of the questions. Write a number in the box at the end of each column, and then total the score from all the questions.
1 = Less than once in 5 times you have urinated
Name: ________________________________________________ Date: ______________ Over the past month, how often have you:
Had the sensation of not completely emptying your bladder after
Had to urinate again less than 2 hours after you finished urinating?
Found that you stopped and started again several times when you
Found it difficult to postpone urination?
Had to push or strain to begin urination?
Had to get up to urinate from the time you went to bed at night
For this question, use the following point scale Total score from all questions QUALITY OF LIFE
If you were to spend the rest of your life with your urinary condition just the way it is now, how would you
feel about that? Circle one answer Delighted Pleased Mostly Unhappy Terrible satisfied dissatisfied MODIFIED INTERNATIONAL INDEX OF ERECTILE FUNCTION (IIEF-5)
This allows objective assessment of any difficulties with erections either before or after surgery. Please answer the questions by putting a tick in the correct numbered box, thinking of the last month.
Please note that if you are not sexually active then this form may not be relevant, in which case please tick here Name: _____________________________________________________ Date: ______________ 1. How do you rate your confidence that you 4. During sexual intercourse, how difficult was it could get and keep an erection? to maintain your erection to completion of intercourse? When you had erections with sexual 5. When you attempted sexual intercourse, how stimulation, how often were your erections often was it satisfactory for you? hard enough for penetration? 3. During sexual intercourse, how often were you Comments: able to maintain your erection after you had penetrated (entered) your partner?
If you are considering this operation on a self pay basis then please contact Nicky on the number
below and she will let you know how to go about that. If you are in good health and have accommodation within 30 miles of central London then there will not be a need to stay in hospital except in rare circumstances. You would need a responsible adult
present to keep an eye on you overnight. At present the total package price for a day case procedure at King’s College Hospital is £4,560.00.
Some men need to plan one night in hospital for reasons not related to the procedure. These may
include heart trouble, social reasons, distance from King’s or immobility (if you have any serious co-existing medical conditions the hospital may not be able to guarantee a package price, although it is
very rare for any complications to occur). A one night stay adds £350.00 to the above cost (total £4,910.00). This option is arranged through King’s Self Pay, administered by BUPA.
At the Lister Hospital the overall costs are a little higher, totalling £4,775.00 for a day case and £5,075.00 for a one night stay. This includes hospital, surgical and anaesthetic fees (these will each be billed separately.)
INSURED PATIENTS This procedure is now covered by BUPA and PPP, and we have agreed treatment packages with them.
As with any relatively new procedure there may sometimes be problems with insurance cover. While insurers will usually remunerate this operation up the level of a TURP prostate resection (code M6530) I would like you to be aware that the surgical and anaesthetic fees will be higher than those
usually remunerated by the insurers for a TURP. For patients not insured by BUPA or PPP, my fee is £1,150.00 which includes any necessary post- operative surgical care or re-operation in the first two weeks. The anaesthetist’s fee is £325.00.
These fees reflect in large part the expense that acquiring this expertise has necessitated, and partly the fact that I see many patients who are either high risk or have very large prostates, due to the
data we have presented on such cases. Although these fees added to the hospital charge for either a day case or one night stay will still usually total less than the cost of the average TURP operation (and much less than open
prostatectomy) you may wish to be aware that insurance companies often have an upper limit which they will remunerate physicians. Were this the case there may well be a shortfall and I would wish
you to be aware of this prior to proceeding. Your insurers may prefer to budget for the package price but you should check with them if you have any concerns, as we are unable to enter into protracted discussions with individual insurers on behalf
of individuals due to the excess time it has taken in the past
NHS PATIENTS I am happy to see NHS patients for this procedure although due to the complexity of the NHS referral
system this can be a little tortuous! If you wish an NHS referral then either your GP or your urologist would need to write to me at:
Dept of Urology, King’s College Hospital, Denmark Hill, London SE5 9RS Our NHS administrators will then make the relevant arrangements for an appointment to be sent out, assuming that there are no funding issues.
Enclosed please find the information pack on having the Green Light Laser procedure done. Costs
while mentioned in the pack are only for the procedure. Other possible costs will be as follows: Preoperative Costs Initial Consultation Operative Costs Lister Hospital (Day Case)
London Bridge Hospital (inc. overnight stay)
Kings College Hospital (inc. overnight stay)
Postoperative Costs Consultation
Please note prices are subject to changes and will need to be confirmed when booking the procedure.
Diabetes Centre Queen Alexandra Hospital Diabetes Review Winter 2011 Focus On: Oral Hypoglycaemics Learning From Recurrent Clinical Incidents Clinical Incident: Continuation of Pioglitazone following Drug and clinical management incidents patient admission with heart failure repeatedly occur within the day to day Learning Point: management of diabetes. The
Gordon Muir, FRCS (Urol) FEBU