Conduct of seminars, discussions, round-tables and workshops devoted to the boardaspects of telecommunications policy, organisation, performance, technology re-search, consumer protection, telecom laws, etc., Involving providers and consumersof service, economists, intellectuals and policy makers;
ICTs AND SOCIETY
Involving consumer associations and providers of service in discussions;
Editor : Dr. T.H. Chowdary
Bringing out Monographs / and a Monthly Journal.
The demonopolisation of Indian telecoms in distorted - unequal competition between
May/June 2011
government and BSNL/MTNL against P-Telcos; unjustly impossed interconnection;revenue shares, access deficit charges, different charges for termination of calls onBSNL/MTML network for India & foreign-originated calls, etc., The CMS would Studyand agitate these issues.
Instigations, companies and individual can join the CTMS be becoming
WORLD TELECOM DAY ISSUE
Institutional Members, (Rs. 5000 one time. Life time)
Annual subscribers (Rs. 250/- per year) to the Journal of CTMs (a monthly).
Members will be invited to CTMs Lectures, Workshops, Seminars and Round Tablesand will be entitled to 10% discount.
Payments may be made by cheque or draft, crossed “account payee”, drawn in
World Telecommunication and
favour of the “Centre for Telecommunications Management and Studies and mailed
Information Society Day, 17 May 2011
to Dr. T.H. Chowdary, Director, CTMS, No. 8 P&T Colony, Karkhana,
Towards a New Telecom Policy
Secunderabad - 500 009. A.P. India (Please add Rs. 20/- for outstation cheques). The Web and the Internet –
Please give your a) Address for mailing b) Your profession c) Organisation
Evolution into Global Brain and Mind
d) Position e) Telephone, f) and E-mail. Election Watch and Voter Education Society Software Racing Towards Mindware Can Development Ensure Re-election of a Governing Party BOOK - POST Resolution on the Financial Viability of BSNL Resolution on 2G Spectrum Scam The New Telecom Policy (NTP) – 2011 R&D and Production within India (Journal of the Center for If undelivered please return to : The Director, Telecom Management and Studies)
CTMS, No. 8, P&T Colony, Karkhana (Secunderabad), Hyderabad - 500 009. A.P. India.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
World Telecommunication and
less educated, and more deprived cousins of the world’s urban
Information Society Day, 17 May 2011
citizens. Among them are as many as 1.4 billion of the world’sextremely poor people, who are also among the least connected to
Message from Dr Hamadoun I. Touré,
the benefits of ICTs. We cannot allow this situation to continue. It is
ITU Secretary-General
time for global action to connect rural communities to the opportu-
Better Life in Rural Communities with ICTs
ITU is committed to connecting the world and to ensuring that thebenefits of ICTs reach the remotest corners as well as the most
ICTs are constantly reshaping the way the world communicates while
vulnerable communities. I am proud to say that our work at ITU in
creating opportunities for a better life through long-term,
developing the standards for ICTs, managing vital spectrum and
sustainable development, not least among the most disadvantaged
orbital resources, mobilizing the necessary technical, human and
financial resources, and strengthening emergency response in theaftermath of devastating natural disasters has met with unprecedented
This year, as we celebrate ITU’s 146th anniversary, we focus our
success as we enter the second decade of this millennium.
attention on the world’s rural communities in our quest to connectthe remotest corners to the benefits of ICTs.
Although mobile penetration has spread rapidly with over 5.3billion subscribers worldwide, the thrust now is to drive content
Today, ICTs are the powerhouses of the global economy and offer
through enhanced broadband access aimed at establishing the
real solutions towards generating sustainable economic growth and
information and communication highways — networks that will feed
prosperity. ICTs also act as catalysts in accelerating progress
both rural communities and urban centres with the means to meet
towards meeting the Millennium Development Goals.
their development goals and aspirations. ITU’s leadership role inthe Broadband Commission for Digital Development is aimed at
In the rural context, ICTs provide enhanced opportunities to
increasing the roll out of this state-of-the-art technology to firmly
generate income and combat poverty, hunger, ill health and
establish a universally accessible knowledge-based information
illiteracy. ICTs and related e-applications are key instruments in
improving governance and rural services, such as providingcommunity health care, safe drinking water and sanitation,
I urge you to celebrate World Telecommunication and Information
education, food and shelter; improving maternal health and
Society Day this year by focusing on connecting people around the
reducing child mortality; empowering women and the more
world and harnessing the full potential of ICTs so that we can all
vulnerable members of society; and ensuring environmental
enjoy a more productive, peaceful and - in every way - a better life,
Half the world’s population — nearly 3.5 billion people — resides
Hamadoun I. Touré
in rural districts and far flung communities, representing the poorer,
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Towards a New Telecom Policy
person is dead. This dream of his envisaged a telephone in thehand or on the body of every person. When it is so, he must answer
It is nothing short of amazing that we have over 800 mln telephones
when there is a call. No answer must signify that he is dead.
now, 80 times more than we had in 1994, when for the first time aNational Telecom Policy ( NTP-‘94) was announced. These 800mln compared with the 80,000 telephones we had at that time of
The National Telecom Policy (NTP- ’94) which was our beginning
Independence in 1947 (10,000 times increase). No other sector has
for demonopolisation, had a number of imperfections which
seen such a startling expansion as the telecoms, in India or any-
militated against rapid expansion of mobile telephony. We put in
where else in the world. Because of demonopolisation, privatization
place this statutory Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI).
and competition and statutory regulation actions which though
That went on improving its understanding and therefore facilitation
riddled with imperfections and distortions in implementation, have
and regulation of pluralism and competition on a level playing field.
by now put a telephone in the hands of 75% of the population.
It was achieved by the enunciation of the NTP in 1999 (NTP-‘99).
The telephone has become affordable to ordinary mass of people as
This removed almost all distortions and disabilities in the free
within Rs. 125 the daily wage for a worker under the NREG, one
play of market forces in telecoms. The most significant corrective
could talk for about 200 minutes; the average annual spend by a
was that the telephone companies were migrated from upfront
cellphone user is Rs. 2,500; one-sixteenth the per capita income,
disabling heavy payment of licence fees to revenues sharing.
while in 1994 it was costing as much as the annual per capital
This was a daring policy by the NDA government. The businesses
income. In our metro cities, there are between 120 to 150
matched this daring by introducing pre-paid class of service. Instead of a person being billed after a month or so of service and
telephones for 100 persons; our urban teledensity is over 80 and
then the companies trying to collect them, over some further
the rural teledensity is more than 30. That means that almost every
period; users can buy some minutes of service for a specified
family has got a telephone. This is borne out by the fact that even
sum. This is called prepaid. This is a great innovation. Because of
daily rated mazdoors and beggars are sporting a cellphone. Now
this mazdoors and house maids and even beggars are able to have
that we have number portability, people may not have names but
phone service for a certain amount. They are purchasing the
everyone can surely have a number. While the names like Nitin,
prepared service. 95% of the subscribers are now prepaid. The
Chitin, Piyush etc., may not be expressive of a person, the tele-
companies are getting money even before service is rendered. That
phone number does express. For eg: a telephone (40) 2374-4567
is helping their cash flow and working capital requirement. There
means Hyderabad, Srinagar Colony and in that some person. A
are no unpaid bills. The prepaid tariff is thus a boon to companies
number like (11) 2611-2345 is expressive of a person living in the
Jorbagh area of New Delhi. Systematic allocation of cell phonenumbers is also possible. Then the vision of I.H Ronnes the
We are now having upto 12 competing companies in most of the
Chairman of the famed American Telegraph and Telephone
states. No country in the world, not even America or China is
Corporation, AT&T in the 1960s that soon enough persons need not
having so many competitors in a given area. More and more
have names but everyone born will be having a telephone number
licenses are being given by the UPA government. A Communica-
and that if, that number is rung and there is no answer, it means the
tions Minister has found in the issuance of licenses an excellent
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
device for illegal moneymaking. All sorts of people have been
2010 –‘11 the losses would be over Rs. 5000 cr and they would
bro ught int o the sector by the ill-intentio ned politician.
further increases year after year. Former state -owned monopolies
Spectrum has been dis-linked from licenses to provide service which
could flourish only because of monopoly. Monopoly militated
is very very unusual. Without spectrum, the license has no meaning
against infusion of new technologies introduction of new services
at all. The licensing and spectrum allotment bear the characteristic
and improvement in the productivity of the employees. Transition
of the permit-licence- quota Nehruvian socialism which has been
from state- owned monopoly into perfect market competition, on
profitably utilized by ill-intentioned Ministers. The result is that,
a level playing field is not easy. It requires noble men with great
we have one of the worst scams which has no parallel anywhere in
vision to effect it. Employees and officers of the former Videsh
the world. The Minister and his associates are all in jail ( albeit
Sanchar Nigam Limited (VSNL) co-operated for its privatization.
temporarily as under trials) and are facing inquiries. The nexus
In its new form, Tata Communications has emerged as a global
between the political master and the scheming companies is what
player acquiring even national carriers like the Teleglobe of Canada.
is known as crony capitalism. Crony capitalism brought ruin to the
If BSNL were led by peoples and vigorous and determination, it
economies of Malaysia, Thailand, Korea and some other South East
could be ten times more powerful and extensive than the VSNL
Asian countries. Civil society and some opposition parties are
/ Tata Communications. Unfortunately, the top bosses belonging to
demonstrating the virtues and power of an open society and
the Indian Telecom Service (all engineers) have chosen very wrong
democratic governance by exposing the corruption that crony
path of not getting absorbed in the company. They are continuing to
be on deputation. Deputationists have no stake in the fortunes ofthe company. Their promotions and salaries and even bonuses are
Just as NTP-‘ 99 was the corrective to NPT-’94, we have to have a
absolutely guaranteed by government. About 1800 of these offic-
corrective to the NTP-‘99. It is good that policy is periodically
ers are, for more than 10 years on deputation, a phenomenon not
reviewed and distortions are removed. The first corrective that is
extent in any company in the country. They and the militant unions
necessary is to reduce the number of competing companies from
are unwittingly helping the decline and demise of BSNL. It would
12 to 4 or 5. That means facilitat ion of mergers and
be a national loss. We always need a state- owned company to be a
acquisitions(M&A). It requires honest thinking and intelligent
corrective and service provider of last resort, especially in
implementation to achieve proper M&As to reduce the number of
national emergencies. And since such a one is wanted, we can
competing companies. The cutthroat competition has brought prices
countenance certain financial help until the company becomes as
below sustainable levels . Some companies are already on the
agile as any private company. This requires a dedicated visionary
down -ward slide in regard to their surpluses. With mergers and
acquisitions the situation can be corrected before that a disasterstrikes and scramblers prevail upon government to bail them out, by
One evil consequence of liberalisation has been the decline and
demise of indigenous R&D & production of equipments requiredfor the mobile and IT- based valued added service networks. We
The Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) the once great
have been importing equipments (even from China) to the extent
monopoly with service all over the country, is now becoming sick.
of Rs.40,000 cr per year. This is utterly shameful for a country which
In the year 2009 –‘10 it made a loss of over Rs. 1800 cr.; in the year
had an R&D and manufacturing capability in 1948 itself when the
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Indian Telephone Industries Ltd. ITI was founded (IT). The new
movements; in seeing that the various welfare schemes are imple-
National Telecom Policy (NTP-‘11) that would now be fashioned
mented with the least transaction cost and distortions. Although
must have the utmost priority for creation of intellectual property
the cell phone is being used in an ugly fashion quite often (eg. speak-
within the country for future networks. In order to wipe out the
ing on the cellphone throughout the night during train journeys or
shame of repeated imports of successive generations of switching
while moving in lifts and waiting in queues) ordinary people will
equipments, the young Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi facilitated the
soon learn to use it in a civilized and cultured manner. Cell phones
setting up of the C-DOT with a mission. Within three years it
will like electricity become inseparable from our daily life. All
accomplished a marvelous outcome – design, development,
services that urban people enjoy by access to the Internet, will be
productionisation and deployment of digital switches that enabled
used by rural people too. If ( besides English) content could be in
us to extend STD and ISD services to rural areas even. We need a
our national languages ( as in China and Russia, Korea and Poland)
C-DOT -like appropriately tasked mission to research, design,
and as broad-band wireless facility gets more widely deployed, the
develop and productonise the 4G equipment & value added
distinction between rural and urban areas will rapidly diminish.
services which would be mostly based on Internet. It is not that wedon’t’ have money. Rs. 36,000 cr have accumulated in theUniversal Service Fund (USF). These are contributions (5%) of the
The Web and the Internet –
revenues from all the telecom cos. Even if a fraction of this amountis utilised for the development of 4G equipment, we would be
Evolution into Global Brain and Mind
In 1887 a Russian, Ludwig Lazarus Zamenhof advocated a Univer-sal language which can be understood and spoken by people of all
As we have been pleading, there is need for a national ICT
nations so that understanding can be promoted between different
University funded by the USF. Such a university and the second
nations. He called that language, Esperanto. He signed his memo-
C-DOT type mission, should be able to correct the blunder we
randum as Doktoro Esperanto which meant Doctor Hopeful.
have committed in allowing indigenous R&D to die. In regard to
He wanted to convey that a common language is the hope of
the telecom regulator, what is most need that the TRAI sets up
mankind to promote understanding, preserve peace and promote
regional offices in all state capitals and builds up users’ societies as
fraternity. In 1911 the great leader and President of the Republic of
a countervailing force to correct the companies’ in their folly of
China, Dr. Sun Yat Sen wanted to adopt Esperanto as language of
gaining numbers at the cost of Quality of Service (QOS).
the Chinese but that did not come about. The idea remained in theair. While a common language for all men could not come, a
As the Secretary General of the ITU has envisaged, rural life can be
language between all machines has come up. This is, TCP/IP –
better by extensive use of ICTs. That it is already being evidenced
Transmission Control Protocol / Internet Protocol. This TCP/IP as
can be seen from the fact that migrant workers with cell phones are
a language of machines all over the world connected on the Internet
able to be in constant communications with their families in the
has been pioneered and promoted by Vint Cerf and Robert E.Kahn.
rural areas. Like electricity, the mobile phones which are
They mooted this idea in 1973 and by now all the five billion
improving functionally continuously are putting power into the hands
computers in the world talk to one another over the Internet in the
of ordinary citizens. They are able to participate in social
machine language (called protocols) TCP/IP.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
One Harvard Professor, JCR Lickleader later, a scientist in the
is electronified, digitized, stored in solid state memory chips and
Advanced Research Projects Administration (ARPA) of the
put into these websites. These are connected to the global telecom
Department of Defense (DOD) of the USA envisioned in April 1963
network of networks, the Internet. Any person who is equipped with
an inter -galactic network of computers. ARPA was tasked to
an appropriate device can gain access to these hundreds of mil-
develop and construct an indestructible telecom network which
lions of websites and can look at and down load the information.
would not be disrupted by a nuclear exchange between the formerUSSR and USA. ARPA became DARPA – Defense Advanced
There is another great invention, the Search Engine. There are
Research Projects Administration funded by the DOD. Informa-
quite a few like Yahoo and Altavista but the greatest of all is the
tion would be electronified, digitized, put in packets and these will
Google. Every month Google is answering eight billion inquires
be transmitted on alternate routes. If one route is destroyed, there
and each one within seconds. Two thirds of the total inquires in the
are still other routes to be used. Scores of research establishment
entire world are answered by this Google search engine, whose
and universities in the USA were also allowed to use the DARPA
algorithm, Page Rank takes into account five hundred million
network. Over time, it morphed into the Inter-network we now know.
variables and two billion terms and therefore gives the most
This is now globe -guddling and is becoming universal because
credible answer to the search. Google was founded by two Russian
cell phones in the hands of over five billion people ( of the 7 bln
Jews Sergie Brin and Larry Page who emigrated from anti-Semitic,
population of the world) are coming to have access to the Internet.
communist tyranny of that country to the freedom of the USA. Stanford University gave them the facility to develop and test the
The Internet has become a store -house of humanity’s information
algorithm and launch the company, Google Inc.
& knowledge, accumulated over centuries. This is being addedupon now because of another revolutionary invention the World
Yet another revolutionary invention that would enable any human
Wide Web – WWW. Tim Berners Lee a mathematician, son of
being to gain access to the Internet to all its websites is by Steve
mathematics teachers of Scotland was working at CERN in Berne.
Jobs who together with Wozniock founded the Apple Comput-
CERN stands for – European Center for Nuclear Research. Lee is
ers. Steve Jobs was kicked out of the company but later on, he
an idealist. Alexander Graham Bell was given the patent for the
rejoined it. His inventions the iPod, iPad and iPhone devices are
invention of the telephone. He commercialized it through the
computers, besides being telephones. The iPhone incorporates a
famous American Telephone and Telegraph Corporation (AT&T)
search engine also. There are two competitive parallel
and later, the Western Electric and the Bell Laboratories. Lee
developments, one spearheaded by Google and the other by Apple.
however, being an idealist did not want to patent his great
Google search in fact, has become a Google Church because, Brin
invention. He opined that all mankind should benefit by the
is advocating that memory should be outsourced, men need not invention of every scientist – the same idea that the Indian
unnecessarily strain their brain with memorizing but that all memory
Sages and Savants cherished through the millennia. The WWW
and search should be outsourced and the Google engine will present
now is a great system. There are a few hundred million websites
to every seeker any information that they want, if it does exists.
some of countries, some of companies, some of individuals, someof universities, some of research labs; indeed by every kind of
While the preceding 250 years until the mid 1950s added and ex-
person and institution. All information (voice, text and pictures)
tended the physical strength of man, since the last sixty years, it is
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
the brain power of man that is being extended through computers
Election Watch and Voter Education Society
and Internet and the search engines. What Lickleader envisaged asthe Galactic Network is already the planetary network. Since all
The Chief Election Commissioner of India deserves to be congratu-
the information leading to knowledge is stored in millions of
lated for his concern about corruption and money power that are
websites interconnected by Internet, we can say this is the Global
bringing disrepute to Indian democracy. In fact, the main cause for
brain storing humanity’s information accumulated through the
corruption in India is the need for political parties and politicians
centuries and is being added on. A global brain, a global memory,
to acquire black money for spending in the elections. It is common
a global network – could this lead to superman that the sage,
knowledge that in the coastal parliamentary constituencies in
Aurobindo envisioned. A super- man is possible, if he has got a
Andhra Pradesh the two principal contestants are having to spend
super brain progressing towards the divine. When man becomes a
an amount of Rs. 50 cr each to get elected to the Lok Sabha. super man can life be divine life again, as envisaged by sage
Enormous amounts are being spent by the candidate for election to
Aurobindo.
the Legislative Assembly, Zilla Parishad, Mandals and evenPanchayats. Once elected, they are using their positions including
A spectacular development is in the making. That is, the Internet
that as Ministers missions to collect money in various means. The
of Things. While there are only seven billion people, things like Air
country is sick with the stories of the recent scandals - the 2G
Conditioners, microwave, refrigerator, the TV set, the door opener,
spectrum, Common Wealth Games, IPL, the s-band and so on.
the security surveillance and such devices are more than 50 billionalready. Each one of them would be fitted with a sensor of the size
There is a need for a Statutory Regulator for political parties in
of one cubic millimeter and that accommodates the equipment to
India, just as we have statutory regulators for telecom, for
wirelessly communicate with Internet, whatever the sensor has
insurance, for stock exchange, for banks and so on. A paper that I
sensed. The Internet of Things and of human beings will evolve
had written about a Regulatory Authority for Political Parties is
into a neural network imitating our own brain. Physiologists are
exploring the brain, mind, memory and when matter would haveconsciousness. All these underlie the mystery of life, birth, death,
Ending creation of such a Regulatory body, the Election
soul, space, time and cosmos. It would not be an exaggeration to
Commission as may encouraged and assist the formation to start
say that scientists and engineers are trying to mimic the human
with in every state capital Election Watch and Voter Education
brain in the global computer network of hundreds of millions of
Societies (EWVES). The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
websites. We shall gratefully remember the great inventors - Tim
(TRAI) is recognizing consumer bodies and is having regular
Bereners Lee, Ludwig Lazarus Zamenhof, Vint Cerf and Robert
consultations with them. They are only at an elementary stage.
E.Kahn, JCR Lickleader, Sergie Brin and Larry Page, Wozniock
EWVESs will have to be funded by the Election Commission. To
regulate these bodies a constitution and rules and regulations maybe drawn up. These bodies may be registered with the Electioncommission. It may give recognition after due scrutiny about thebonafidies and integrity of those who initially form them.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Some of the important functions of EWVES are:
Software Racing Towards Mindware
To monitor the political rallies and activities and demon-
(Abstract of talk delivered at Guru Ghasidas University,
strations and bandhs of political parties ; estimate the
Bilaspur)
expense for organizing that ; call upon the organsing politi-cal parties to comment upon these estimated expenditures
Inventions in the 19th century and the first half of the 20th centuries
and require them to disclose the sources of funds .
extended man’s physical power enormously taking man to other
Pressurize political parties to disclose their collections/in-
planets and launching exploratory laboratories into space.
comes and their sources and the expenditure and requirethem to be published every quarter just like public limited
The second half of the 20th century and the first decade following
companies are required to publish their accounts every quar-
it have been seeing inventions that are extending the brain and
mind power of man which may lead to the evolution of a super -
Political parties are promising various types of welfare
mind and superman as envisioned by the sage, Aurobindo Ghosh .
measures. They should be called upon to estimate the an-nual cost of implementing these measures and explain
Computers & software as parts of Information Technology and
how the funds for them will be raised – new taxes, enhanced
Optical Fiber transmission and Communications Satellites are
linking the world’s hundreds of millions of websites which are
Political parties may be asked to appear or to address these
store houses of all the information and knowledge that mankind has
EWVES to put the societies wise as to how they are raising
their funds and whether they are conducting elections to choose the office bearer and in what manner. If there
The Internet is a super -brain network and storage and software are
is no democracy in the political parties, how can we expect
helping even the outsourcing of memory and logic and discovery.
them to safeguard true democracy in the country. We are
Search engines are bringing the most relevant and research
noting that every political party is now owned by one
information in seconds from the global store-houses, the web-sites.
proprietor may be of a dynasty and officer bearers are nomi-
This will profoundly affect the evolution of brain and capability of
nated by the proprietor of the party under the bogus name
high-command which is in fact I-Command .
There are about, 1.5 bln TV sets, 3 billion computers, 5 bln mobile
The suggestions made in this note require to be considered by
phones and nearly a billion websites. All these numbers will be
responsible intellectuals for which purpose the CEC may kindly
over -shadowed by the things that will have sensors and would be
take the initiative of calling selected people for a discussion. It
communicating from one another and with man. We will be seeing
may begin the process by issuing a consultation paper.
the Internet of Things ( microwaves, air-conditioners, burglar alarms, parking space indicators, and the quarter millions items that a super market stores and sells). The Internet of Things connecting to a few hundred billion sensors is what we will be
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
witnessing soon. New devices like the iPhone will abolish the
crore women etc. Chandra Babu could not educate
distinction between phones and PCs . Cloud computing will help us
the public enough about what is lasting good for
save on the costs of infrastructure and of software. Together with
them. His defeats should be a lesson to S/S Narendra
virtualization, cloud computing will save 20% - 30% of the energy
consumed by computing devices, especially data centers. The 4thgeneration network and devices will deliver giga- bits of informa-
During his two terms as Chief Minister Sri Chandrababu Naidu
tion in seconds wheehr moving or stationary. Commoditization of
tremendously succeeded in making the Telugu people conscious of
applications and consumerisation of software will bring down
economic development and good governance. Within a short
the expenses dramatically just like mobile telephones and the pre-
period he had been able to change the mindset and outlook of the
paid business model have brought global telephony into the palms
young and the parents. Hundreds of engineering colleges were started
in the peoples (private) sector Information Technology & Telecom-munications were evangelized as engines of development. A
Letter writing, personal contacts and speculative intellect are giv-
document, Vision 2020 was prepared in 1998 and imaginative and
ing way to new forms of communications interaction and evolu-
inspiring presentations of the contents were made to intellectuals
tion. There is fear that technological advances will bring in Fran-
professionals, government officers universities and colleges. They
kensteins which will overwhelm and subdue our mind. We are wit-
were also the theme of his speeches everywhere. As never before,
ness a convergence of software and mindware and have to face
entrepreneurs were invited from all a quarters of the world. They
the threat of software created by globally interacting intelligent
encouraged to invest and every facility that they wanted to set up
persons subduing man’s mind. What a fearful and prospective fu-
their business or industry was quickly provided. He abolished the
inspector –raj – the visitations of various inspectors to vultureupon the companies for graft. A number of officers enthusiasti-
Can Development Ensure Re-election of a
cally cooperated with him to use their connections in India and
Governing Party
abroad to invite companies and investors to come to the state. Ahigh-rise building- Hitec city was constructed in record time toprovide ready –to- use space (plug and play) for any company to set
(Sri Chandra Babu Naidu has accomplished
up its business and launch its operations. World class broad-band
unprecedented development of Andhra Pradesh
telecoms using satellite and optical fibers connected the city to all
during his Chief Ministership, 1996-2004. But his
continents. He got international air-lines to Hyderabad and built
part lost the Assembly elections in Y 2004 and again
excellent roads in the city. He used his 28 MP strong contingent in
in Y 2009 because his rival, the late Y.S.Rajasekhara
the Lok Sabha to wrest whatever concessions and allocations are
Reddy excited farmers and the poor by the wildest
needed for businesses to take on in the shortest of time, with least
promises of free rations, electricity, health, housing,
red tape. All these endeavors and exertions and exhortations of his
education, marriage, pilgrimage subsidies to
bore fruit – Hyderabad became a shining star on the IT map of
Christians, financial aid for marriage, old age
India. From nowhere, the I.T companies in Hyderabad came up to
pensions, 3% interest loan of Rs. One lakh to one
make the city the fourth largest exporter of software and ITES
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
services. Andhra Pradesh and Chandra Babu Naidu became
agriculture. The great migration of the educated, young to
mascots for India’s IT provess. Sri Naidu succeeded in getting the
Hyderabad and their dazzling incomes were in contrast to “no
legendary Bill Gates of Microsoft and Bill Clinton, the President
change” agriculture on the other side. Many years of his rule also
of USA to the city. These two personalities further brightened the
saw drought which badly told on farmers’ incomes.
image of Andhra Pradesh as the most desirable destination for loca-tion of the world’s companies in Hyderabad. Realizing that the
Sri Naidu had improved the transportation system tremendously.
high paid IT professionals cannot work in a vacuum, Naidu’s gov-
The pot holed roads in Hyderabad appeared like the moon scape
ernment promoted house- building and housing estates; corporate
with numerous creators. The so called state highways and district
hospitals, international schools, tourism, catering and transporta-
roads were in utterly ruined condition. Within a few years the
tion services for the hundreds of thousands of IT professionals work-
quality of all the roads changed and many visitors to the city,
especially the Telugu speaking NRIs from the US really wonderedhow anybody could call India’s roads as abominable . They saw
He won the 1999 elections. His party, TDP returned 28 MPs and the
very good roads in Hyderabad and elsewhere.
BJP with which he was in alliance returned 10 MPs. paving theway for the strong BJP-led NDA government at the center. This
Then came the fatal Lok Sabha elections in 2004. These were
success convinced him to say and propagate that “development is
advanced by six months, entirely on the persuasion of the NDA by
good politics”. He believed that the creation of employment for
Naidu. There was an attempt on Naidu’s life by Maoists in 2003.
the educated, young and so many new services coming up would
He wanted to cash on the sympathy wave. He went in for the
promote entrepreneurship also instead of the young seeking em-
dissolution of the Assembly prematurely in the hope that if
ployment in government. One view of his which though correct
Assembly elections were held immediately, he could win a third
but no music was that farmers was that there is not much prosper-
term. Unfortunately, the Election Commission did not oblige him.
ous future in agriculture and so farmers have to change to other
Naidu persuaded the BJP and its allies in the NDA to go in for
professions. Though farming is essential to the country and it has
premature elections to the Lok Sabha also. These were held six
got to be subsidised as everywhere in the world, prosperity cannot
months in advance of the 5-year life of Lok Sabha and six months
be built by so many farmers with small holdings and inability to put
after the attempt on Naidu’s life. The TDP lost; it drowned the
in required capital to become prosperous like businessmen and
industrialist. The fact, that agriculture is contributing about only18% to the GDP but nearly 70% of the people are dependent upon
Why did not development which was for everybody to see save
agriculture was repeatedly mentioned by him. The fact that agricul-
Naidu & his TDP in Andhra Pradesh and the NDA in Delhi? Devel-
ture- dependency by so many would prevent many to quit poverty
opment alone is not ensuring political dividends. The Congress
and low incomes was stressed. As much effort was put in correctly
party in Andhra Pradesh under the leadership of the late
evangelizing and implementing the development of ICT & other
Dr.Y.S.Rajasekhara Reddy made promises of unlimited welfare.
services, was not put in to explain the transformation that is
Free houses, free food, free schooling, write off of all debts.
required in the attitude of farmers to agriculture. Farmers came to
Government money would be given for the celebration of
think (wrongly) that Naidu was neglecting, if not hostile to
marriages, pensions would be given to all above age 60 years, women
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
would be made lakapathis by giving them loans at pavala vaddi (3%
welfare without any work for them. They are taught that they
interest) which maybe written off eventually, free transport for many,
have a right for everything and no duty at all. The competitive
free electricity for the rural households and farms and the poor,
politics is promising reservations, fee reimbursement and waiver of
health care would be free for all and so on. He also destructively
all loans, taken not only from government and from banks but even
criticised the importance given to the ICTs. He asked would com-
from private money lenders. These wreckless parties and their
puters give water, food, housing, they give work to the hundreds of
governments are inciting people to take loans and also not pay them.
thousands of unemployed people (who he know were all either
In the background of this absolutely irresponsible, mendations
illiterate or hardly literate and unqualified for any services sector
fraudulent, populism of more or less all political parties, economic
jobs excepting physical labour for agriculture etc). He charged
development alone will not make good electoral politics.
that even though 70% of the people are deepening upon a agricul-ture, the Naidu government in imitation of some western countries
Sri Narendra Modi and Sri Nitish Kumar, the Chief Ministers of
is neglecting agriculture; Naidu is an enemy of 70% of the people.
Gujarat and Bihar respectively are doing very well as regards
All these promises and accusations were sweet music to the unem-
economic development and good governance. They must take
ployed and to the agriculture - dependent farmers. Farmer were led
lesson from the failure of Sri Chandra Babu Naidu to win a third
to believe that if Naidu’s TDP won again, that would be the end of
successive term. It is necessary that they become educators from
all farmers ; they would become paupers.
the grassroots level of people. They must give utmost importancefor education for all upto SSLC, ensure good quality of education,
Chandra Babu drove government servants to work; to be punctual,
inculcate work ethic and not talk of right for this and that of
to be responsive to public, to be transparent in decision-making; he
everything. Traditional values of hard work, saving and truthful-
introduced e-procurement to eliminate cartels; he launched villager-
ness and love of the country should be inculcated. Most importantly,
involving, villager-contributing, government-supplementing and
during the period of, development, for rapid rise out of poverty
local official –supervised development works in rural areas under
every family, must be incentive to limit the number of children to
the inspiring name Janmabhoomi works programs. The require-
one or two. It is not possible for a poor country like India to be
ment of hard and sincere, graft-less work by officials did not endear
able to provide all sorts of welfare to all families with large num-
Sri Naidu to the farmer. Some of them secretly loved the defeat of
ber of children. Every type of welfare like fee re-imbursement, sub-
sidized rice/wheat, sugar, kerosene; housing, health, pension, reser-vations should be admissible to families with only two children and
This high level denunciation of Chandra Babu Naidu as an enemy
all these must be withdrawn as soon as a third child comes. There
of agriculturists and government servants finished Chandrababu’s
should be no incentive for unbridled child production; those who
chances for a third successive win. It is therefore clear that empha-
believe that God gives children must be told to appeal to god for the
sis only on economic development and creation of wealth and
r sustenance and welfare and not expect or appeal to government.
growth rates and minimization of corruption will not automatically
Work must be guaranteed to those who are prepared to move to
lead to electoral victories. In the background of widespread
where work is, at project, construction sites; their transport and tented
unemployability and agriculture dependency, these categories of
living and care of children at work sites could be provided from
people are being promised by competing parties all sorts of
project costs. None should be paid for no work. China has been
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
imposing the one- child norm for the last 30 years and inculcating
and it is equal to capital plus reserve and surplus ) as on 31-3-2010 was
the work ethic . Though it is a communist country they are saying
Rs 86476 crores where as the loss was only Rs 1823 crores. Therefore,
“he who not work neither should he eat”. They are not distribut-
there is every chance to prevent BSNL from becoming sick and make itviable in case the trend of posting losses is stopped.
ing money like us through schemes like NREG. They are extractingwork from people where work is and compensating them with wages.
This meeting further notes the fact that several PSUs that became sick
In contrast to what is happening in China, it appears that we are
after facing losses continuously were revived due to the struggles of the
promoting among the poor, the belief, “it is our right to breed; it is
workers for bringing change in Government and management policies
your duty to feed”. Limiting family size to one or two children;
and by improving the work culture and productivity . The Visakhapatnam
compulsory education for all children upto age 14 years and day
Steel Plant ie RINL (Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Limited) posted losses
-in and day- out inculcating the spirit of duty and no talk of rights
continuously after its commissioning and by 1998 its accumulated losseswere Rs 3600 crores which was more than 50% of its net worth ie Rs
must be indulged in by true and honest leaders who want to do
6500 crores and became sick. The then NDA Government decided to
privatise it. It was opposed by CITU and other trade unions and the Gov-ernment was compelled to drop the privatization proposal and to an-nounce a package for the revival of the company. Besides this, the trade
Resolution on the Financial Viability of BSNL
unions brought improvement in the work culture and productivity. Theproductivity of the employees rose from 161 tonnes/man year in
( Courtesy: Tele-Crusader, April 2011)
1998-99 to 240 tonnes/man year in 2000-01. It started to get profits since2000-01 onwards and became a debt free company in October 2003 and
a) This meeting of the CEC of BSNLEU held at Chennai from 22nd to 24th
wiped out all accumulated losses in January 2006. Thereafter, it even
March 2011 notes with serious concern the facts that BSNL posted a loss
achieved Navaratna status. Out of the 42 PSUs under Kerala State
of Rs 1823 Crores in 2009-10, its cash reserves which were Rs 30343
Government, only 12 were making profit in 2005-06 when UDF
crore on 31-3-2010 were almost over, its expenditure is Rs 600 crores
Government was in power. The UDF regime decided to privatise or close
more than its income every month, its income on services has been
down 25 of these loss making PSUs. After LDF Government came into
decreasing at the average rate of Rs 2000 crores per year, its interest on
power in 2006, the, privatisation policy was dropped and it was decided
cash reserves which was Rs 2472 crores in 2009-10 will not be available
to revive these PSUs. Due to the political will of the LDF Government
now due to depletion of the cash reserves, and the compensation of
and co-operation from the trade unions, the number of profit making
Rs 2000 Crores per year to it from USO fund for meeting the losses on
companies increased to 24 in 2006-07 and to 32 by 2009-10. This was
account of rural landlines will not be available from 2011-12 onwards.
done without any retrenchment or VRS. On the other hand in one year,
As per a newspaper report, the loss for BSNL will be about Rs 4000
719 additional jobs were created in these PSUs. These experiences
crore in 2010-11 and Rs 10000 Cr in 2011-12.
establish the fact that it is possible to revive BSNL as a profitable andvibrant PSU. b) However this meeting notes the fact that BSNL is a healthy PSU when
considered from the definition of sick company. As per DPE guidelines
The rural landlines are socially necessary but commercially unviable
a PSU will be declared sick in case its accumulated loss in any financial
and loss making business. BSNL is facing a loss of around Rs 10000
year is equal to or exceeds 50% of its average net worth during the 4
crore on account of rural land lines. At the time of corporatization,
years immediately proceeding such financial year. As per the accounts of
the Government assured to compensate fully for such losses incurred
BSNL for the year 2009-10 its net worth (shareholder’s funds i.e
by BSNL on account of meeting the social obligations. Accordingly,
Government’s funds since government is the 100% share holder in BSNL
it reimbursed licence fee paid by BSNL, and asked the private
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
operators to pay ADC to BSNL and a major portion of this loss was
ment should be completed and equipment purchased without delay.
compensated. But coming under the pressure of the private telecom
Procurement of other equipments and materials should be done
operators led by the Indian and foreign big capitalists, the Govern-
without delay and there should be proper plan for acquiring the
ment stopped the reimbursement of license fee from 1-4-2006 and
equipment with a view to increase the market share of BSNL in all
ADC was stopped from 1-4-2008. Thereafter Rs 2000 crores was
paid every year as compensation for the years 2008-09, 2009-10 and2010-11. This will not be available from 2011-12 onwards. This
V) To prevent the unhealthy and illegal competition in telecom services
meeting appreciates the role of the JAC in organizing struggles which
sector, the licenses of all the private operators who illegally obtained
helped in making the Government to think about extending this
such licenses in the 2G spectrum scam should be cancelled and the
compensation further. This meeting demands the Government to fully
amount swindled by the private operators in the 2G scam must be
compensate BSNL for the losses on account of rural landlines. II) The BSNL as a PSU is having the social obligation of serving the VI) Experts from Government/Public Sector genuinely interested in
cause of national security and hence it cannot and must not adopt
reviving BSNL as a profitable and vibrant PSU be appointed as Board
managed capacity procedure for procuring equipment quickly since
of Directors of BSNL and the vacant posts of CMD and Directors be
the foreign equipment vendors have to install, maintain and operate
filled up immediately. The ITS absorption issue be settled without
the network in such a system. As a PSU it has to give orders to ITI to
the extent of 30% of its requirement and has to follow PSU tenderprocedure in procuring equipment. Since in the interest of national
VII) Management must adopt proper marketing and sales strategies.
security the BSNL is necessarily facing delays in procuring the equip-ment, this aspect also must be taken into consideration while com-
VIII) BSNL should be given the task of completely laying the optic
pensating BSNL for the losses incurred due to social obligation.
fiber cable under National Broadband Plan without creating anyseparate agency for this purpose. III) While the private operators were allowed to bid for 3G license in the
chosen Circles based on commercial considerations, the BSNL was
X) There should be no disinvestment, unbundling and the VRS
compelled to pay a heavy fee of Rs 18500 crores for all circles for
the 3G and BWA spectrum. This operation of 3G and BWA servicesin all circles by BSNL irrespective of commercial considerations
d) This CEC meeting calls upon all BSNL non-executives and executives
has to be recognized as an activity of social obligation being carried
to organize united campaign and struggles for achieving the above
out by it. Moreover as per the New Telecom Policy 1999, BSNL
demands for making BSNL a profitable organization. Since the policies
need not pay any spectrum fee and hence, 3G and BWA spectrum
of the Government against BSNL and in favour of the Indian and foreign
fee. Therefore, the licensee fee of Rs 18500 crores collected from
big capitalists in telecom sector can be changed only with the support of
BSNL on account of 3G and BWA spectrum should be reimbursed.
the people, it is necessary to get such support by going to the people andserving them better. This meeting calls upon all the BSNL non-execu-
IV) The Government must stop political intervention for delaying the
tives and executives to reorient themselves to meet the present require-
procurement of equipment for BSNL and the management must stop
ment and participate in the great task of marketing and selling the BSNL
all corrupt and intentional practices aimed at delaying the procure-
products efficiently and to provide better service to the customers in order
ment of equipment. The 5.5 million lines GSM equipment procure-
to win in the competition. . This meeting appeals to all the members of
ment should be done immediately without any further delay. The e-
parliament irrespective of their political affiliations to put pressure on
tendering process for procurement of 15 million lines GSM equip-
the Government to accept the above demands for making BSNL viable.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Resolution on 2G Spectrum Scam
This meeting of BSNLEU demands that all culprits should be given exem-
plary punishment and the loss to the nation should be made good by ordering
(Courtesy: Tele-Crusader, April 2011)
recoveries from the companies who were favoured by the Minister. Thismeeting further demands that all the illegal licences granted in this 2Gspectrum scam be cancelled and request the union to continue to fight against
The 2G Spectrum scam is the biggest scam in Indian history. According to
all sorts of corruption in the telecom sector.
the CAG, the loss to the nation is estimated to be to the tune of Rs 1.76 lakhcrore. The entire nation was shocked at the revelation of CAG. The New Telecom Policy (NTP) – 2011
While issuing the licences, A.Raja ignored the advice of the Prime
(Text of the letter written to Sri Kapil Sibal, Minister for IT &
Minister, Law Ministry, Finance Ministry, the guidelines of TRAI and DOT. Communications )
Many companies who were allotted 2G spectrums did not fulfill DOTconditions of eligibility. Many companies had no infrastructure to providetelecom services. Some companies were in real estate business. The
Special items to be taken care of:
companies holding 85 out of 122 linceses did not fulfill eligibility criterion.
1. A new “C-DOT” for 4G :
For example, Swan Telecom, Unitech and S Tel sold a big chunk of their
With the demise of the C-DOT and the disappearance of the
shares to other companies thus getting huge profits within few months ofpurchasing 2G spectrum.
Telecom Research Center of the DOT, there is no design, develop-ment and productionisation indigenously for the equipment required
A.Raja acted in an arbitrary manner. He changed the cutoff date to benefit
for the 2G, 3G, and 4G ICT equipments. We are importing the
certain companies. He followed the “first come first served” method instead
equipments from all over the world, mainly from China, Finland,
The previous session of parliament could not conduct any business on the
demand of JPC Committee to probe the scam by the opposition. The Govern-
1.2 It will be a shame for India to continue to do so. The C-DOT
ment had to accept the JPC demand before beginning of the present budget
was tasked with a mission and it delivered excellent results, with
of course the then Prime Minister’s personal patronage. The newTelecom Policy 2011 should provide for a C-DOT type missioned
The Prime Minister though knew everything but he remained a mute spec-
tator. The CBI also dilly dallied on the issue. It was only after Supreme Court
organisation to design, develop and productionise the 4G
reprimanded the CBI that A.Raja was arrested and put behind bars. But ironi-
equipments. We have about Rs. 30,000 cr in the Universal Service
cally, the new incumbent, Shri Kapil Sibal, stated that there is no loss to the
Fund (USF), part of it should be utilized for the development of the
exchequer. The minister was pulled up by the Supreme Court. Along with the
Minister A.Raja some officers were also arrested. The CBI investigation isgoing on and a charge sheet is expected to be filed by the end of this month.
2. National ICT University:
Earlier there used to be corruption to the tune of hundreds or thousands of
In order to faster excellence and inventiveness among the Indian
rupees because it related to grant of permits/tenders/licences. But in this era
young especially the executives of the telephone companies and of
of liberalization and globalization the corruption is to change the
them the state-owned BSNL & MTNL it would be appropriate that
Government policies in favour of MNCs/ big business houses and hence the
we have a National ICT University. This could be funded/patron-
volume of corruption is in thousands of crores.
ized by the DOT by utilizing some part of the USF.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
2.2 This university should be engaged in applied research &
the companies do care for customers and if they don’t, they will be
development for advancement of ICTs. Countries like Malaysia and
punished, the TRAI must open regional offices in every state Head
Bulgaria have national telecom universities, funded by the State. Quarter to begin with and other important towns by and by. The
China has the Beiging University of Posts & Telecoms (BUPT) which
TRAI must organise and assist user bodies and fund them so that
has been spearheading R&D development effort in the country for
they are effective under the leadership and patronage of the re-
the benefit of companies like ZTE and Huawei. It may be good that
our ALTTC at Ghaziabad itself should be reshaped into theNational ICT university. We may add faculties in economics,
6.2 Telephone Adalats:
banking, finance, sociology informatisation of society and telecom
It should be a mandatory, condition of the licence that every Telco
holds a Telephone Adalat for its customers just as BSNL has beendoing. This provision must be incorporated in the new National
3. Broadband Internet connection in every college and class room of university level: We are having about 2500 colleges in the country and over 500
7. Indian Information Society:
universities including the private ones. The Universal Service
In order to study the Impact of the cell phone and the Internet and
Fund should be utilised to put broadband Internet connection in all
broadband on the WWW, electronic funds transfer, e-commerce,
these institutions besides all our R&D centers in the government
e-procurement and so on and formulate appropriate government
sector and selected ones in the private sector.
policies for the informatising society, the NTP should bring intobeing a National Institute for Information Society. One such has
4. Electronic Class Rooms:
been in existence in Korea. It was under its impact that the
In all the 3,200 engineering colleges and the several hundred Poly-
government involved itself in extending broadband to every
technics we should have electronic classrooms, one at least for
habitation throughout Korea. That is why Korea has the highest
each branch of engineering/ polytechnic. These should be linked
broadband penetration in the world. The parallels of Korea’s KETRI
either via the satellite or broadband Optical Fibre so that a lecture
(Koreas Electronic & Telecom Research Institute) and Korea
that is delivered in any college is simulcast in all the thousands
Information Society Development Institute of the about 125
colleges in an interactive way. This will add to the excellence in
employees have more than 100 are non-engineers – economists,
teaching from selected masters of teaching.
sociologists, anthropologists, historians, lawyers, literary fellowsto assist them in envisioning an Information Society by extensive
5. A National Telecom Museum:
use of ICTs , about a score ICT professionals are also in this insti-
We should have one such in Delhi and in every state capital. We
should collect all the old telephones from the magneto to thecentral battery, the dial and the push button instruments plus the
8. National ICT Consultative Council:
strowger, cross bar and analogue electronic exchange equipments
This may consist of academicians and industrialists and business-
that are being retied. These should be put up in the National Telecom
men from all sectors of the society. There should be eminent
persons who have been deliberating and advocating policies for the
6. Regional Offices of the TRAI:
entire nation. This maybe meet twice or thrice a year to review the
6.1 While there is perfect market competition and companies are
ICT use the broadband penetration, the effects of the ICT use and
putting enormous effort to gain customers, there is an woeful
society, development of intellectual property and manufacturing
inattention to customer complaints, grievances and their redressal,
capacity within the country and the social impact of telephone,
especially in Quality of Service (QOS). Unless the countervailing
internet penetration on the way that people work, learn and
power of the customer is brought to bear upon the companies, the
socialize. It may also advocate legislation like banning cell phone
numbers may grow but the QOS may not. In order to ensure that
talk while walking, driving, in the lifts, in queues, public places
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
and planes and so on. It should review the cases of crime on the
R&D and Production within India
Internet and the mobile network and advocate policies andlegislation to minimise the crimes. (Talk at College of Defense & ISB, Hyd) Notes & News : Prosperity & Power Telecom Licenses
Prosperity cannot be achieved without industrialisation
Prosperity can’t be maintained and defended without power.
Ever since he has taken over the Ministry of Communications Sri
Power alone deters aggression, subversion and subjugation
Kapil Sibal has been speaking far too often and pontifically about
telecom policies and licenses. Now he says that the licenses wouldrequire to be renewed every 10 years. Can thousands of crores of
Intellectual Property
rupees be invested in a network if the tenor of the licences is only10 years ? Then there is the uncertainty of its renewal. If he truly
Industrialisation, prosperity and maintenance of power need
enforces the 10 year rule, then it means that the government is
indigenous creation of Intellectual Property ( IP) by us,
resurrecting the permit-licence –quota system by which politi-
for us, owned by us and made available to stimulated
cians in power can make huge monetory gains. entrepreneurs in India.
This means R&D on a massive scale on several fronts for
Sri Sibal’s view that acquisitions and mergers should be facilitated
several products and systems as a National Mission under
so that in any state there are no more than 5 or 6 competing Telcos
leadership of government and partnership with private
is a very sound idea. We have far too much competition which is
Indian companies and universities, drawing upon the global
already leading to ever falling prices, threatening the financial health
Indian intellectual professionals.
and therefore survival of the Telcos. Ethical India BSNL’s Price Reductions
India, as every good and great nation must be ethical inregard to use of prosperity, power and Intellectual Property
The BSNL Hyderabad announced that it will give the 3G services
(discoveries, inventions, processes, applications, sharing) to
free! (Ind. Express 14/4/11) This is on top of a 75% reduction in
realise our eternal aspiration Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam.
the broad band tariff. It has already declined from the 1st to the 5thposition among. Telcos; it incurred a loss of Rs 1500 cr in the year
Civilian R&D spend as % of GDP
2009-‘10 and the losses in the fiscal 2011 are expected to be Rs. 5000 cr. Why then BSNL reducing the prices? Is it imitating the
continuously loss making Indian Airlines which has reduced its
fares by 20% recently? Reduction in fares and charges and freeservices are good for consumers but this could only be for a little
while as the company would die soon. In the quest for arresting the
fall in market share, the PSUs seem to be committing suicide.
This is not good for the country. Sri Kapil Sibal will do well to stop
the financially meaningless rate reductions by BSNL.
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Patents applied and granted in the period 2004 to 2008 Example of National Missions
The Manhattan project for production of the first nuclear
USSR’s space programs and nuclear weapon
China: Development of intellectual property for obligation
in several sectors including rocketry, satellites , telecoms,
IT and construction and manufacturing. What should we do
Set national goals for creation of intellectual property sec-
Multi disciplinary Task Force for project formulation and
Dismal past
build up of the organisation like the Oakridge Project ( and
In telecom, foreign technologies were successively imported
from 1948 and the practice continues.
Indian companies shut out from R&D and production while
This was characteristic of the socialistic pattern adopted by
Over Rs 35,000 cr paid by Telcos as Universal Service
the Great Leader under which the state and state sector
Fund (USF) is lying unutilised. Telcos are contributing 5%
companies were to occupy the commanding heights of
of their revenues for this USF. It is not less than Rs.10,000
For Defense too most equipments and systems are imported
Utilise USF to seed the R&D efforts including in the ICT
just like in telecom. The difference was that in telecom there
was production using imported technology, while in De-
Contract out R&D (like the DOD of USA)to private com-
fense probably the equipments were imported lock, stock,
panies, so that the emoluments for the Researchers can be
and barrel, notwithstanding our having a string of excellent
substantial like in the private sector ( and not a fraction in
Examples of indigenous capability Most important
Our space Technology and Satellites and Rocketry
Nuclear Reactor, design and commissioning.
The short lived C-DOT ‘s achievements in telecoms switch-
Consensus and not conflict (political) in regard to national
Design and construction and commissioning of Airports byprivate companies
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
CENTRE FOR TELECOMMUNICATIONS Books By Dr. T.H. Chowdary MANAGEMENT AND STUDIES (CTMS)
The Center for Telecommunications Management and Studies (CTMS) is a
(Telephone Cheppin kothalu in Telugu-First person narrations of Telecom personswhile on duty) (1981).
nonprofit institution registered as a Trust. It was founded in 1989 with the primary
(Plays with telegraph & telephone services as themes) (Telugu) (1982).
Telecommunications as a facilitating infrastructure for the economic development of
(delineaion of the duties, functions andwork of Dots employees) (1982)
RIGHT NUMBER : CHEAP SERVICE, TELEPHNE UNLIMITED
Information as critical resource for enabling people to advance and achieve.
(Play on how telephone services are administered by techno-bureaucrats and ministers) (1983)
Technological changes affecting generation, sorage, processing and distribution ofinformation on the one hand and abundance, affordability and variety of telecommu-
TELEPHONING RURAL ARE AS OF ANDHRA PRADESH (1987)
The convergence of computers and communications leading to transformation of
(The story of his struggles in the DoT to deviver service and not merely administer ruls) (1990)Rs.60/-
telecoms into electronic/photonic highways for transportation of information tele-
ISSUES IN TELECOM DE-MONOPOLISATION IN INDIA (1999) Rs. 100/-
INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIS INTO THE NEW
How rural telecoms as well as world class telecom and information service could be
THE DYNASTRY AND CORRUPTION (1999) Rs. 5/-
What type of telecom organisations are appropriate for development, for productionof equipment and or provision of services.
How could the consumer’s need be met and his choice be protected.
INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNLOGIES FOR
How the citizen’s right to know, his freedom for choice can be protected.
How the prices for facilities and services are to be related to costs and how costs
must be ascertainable by regulators and consumers.
What should be the structure and scope of regulation and what talents are neces-
ALOCHINCHANDI (Telugu) (2007) Second Print, 2008
How the universalisation of information and democatisation (people orientation or
YEDHECHHASI TATHAKURU (Telugu) (2008) Rs. 100/-
people satisfaction) of telecoms can be achieved.
TAMSOMA JYOTIRGAMAYA (Telugu) (2008) Rs. 100/-
How information technology can change our lives and economy and how it can bedeveloped to serve masses and classes alike.
ADIGI TELUSUKONDI (Telugu) (2008) Rs. 60/-
How Telecommunications and IT can be engines of education, employment and
how jobs can be taken to small towns and villages.
TELECOMS, IT AND SOCIETY (2009) Rs. 100/-
E-governance, services delivery and information of society are to be brought about
VASTAVALANU GAMANICHANDI (2009) Rs. 100/-
How society and family life will be affected by extensive use of ICTs.
Bharatiya Pragna (Since 1996)“Secularism” Combat (since 2003)
How work from all quarters of the world (BPO, KPO, ITES, Software services) canbe taken to India’s villages to urbanise villages instead of “slumnifying” towns andcities by moving job-seekers to urban areas.
These objectives are sought to be achieved by
DR. T.H. CHOWDARY and owned by him for the CTMS
Organising training courses for telecommunication managers, for large users of tele
communication to enable them to plan, construct, operate and maintain intracom-
pany, multi-site telecommunications systems, organisations, price fixation and re-
(Secunderabad) Hyderabad - 500 009. A.P. India.
: +91 (40) 6667 - 1191 (O), 2784-3121 (R)
1) [email protected]) www.drthchowdary.net
All Copy rights renounced to facilitate propagation of facts and truth. Articles in theJournal may be freely reproduced. Just give credit to the Journal (s)
Printed at Goutham Printers, Domalguda - 9949930670
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
Information & Communication Technologis (ICT’s) and Society, May/June 2011
2:08-cv-02133-MPM-DGB # 152 Page 1 of 33 Thursday, 20 September, 2012 11:38:16 AM UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS URBANA DIVISION ____________________________________________________________________________ NECA-IBEW PENSION TRUST FUND, NECA-IBEW WELFARE TRUST FUND, and INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS LOCAL UNION Case No. 08-CV
Dia: 04 de setembro de 2011 • Horário: das 09 às 13h Duração: 04 (quatro) horas, incluído o tempo para o preenchimento do cartão-resposta 1. Aguarde autorização para abrir o caderno resposta por erro de preenchimento ou por rasuras feitas pelo candidato. A marcação de 2. Confira seu número de inscrição e nome. 3. A interpretação das questões é parte do processo d